skzbrust (skzbrust) wrote,
skzbrust
skzbrust

Reflections on Evolution

I recently learned, to my surprise, that the theory of evolution, in broad and carefully tiptoeing around the question of Man, was largely accepted in the scientific community before Darwin, but they were unable to answer the question, "What exactly is the mechanism?"   When Darwin answered this question with his discovery of natural selection,  not only did it generate outrage against his discovery, but the outrage then extended back to the theory of evolution itself, which became associated with his name.

In the mid 1800s, the labor theory of value ("the value of a commodity is equal to the labor necessary to produce it") was largely accepted among political economists; but they were unable to answer the question: "Where, then, does profit come from?"  When Marx answered this question with his discovery of labor-power and surplus value, not only did it generate outrage against his discovery, but the outrage then extended back to the labor theory of value itself, which became associated with his name.

I can't help but wonder how often this has happened in the scientific community. 

Anyway, let me finish with a quotation:   "Man may be excused for feeling some pride in having risen, though not through his own exertions, to the very summit of the organic scale; and the fact of his having thus risen, instead of having been aboriginally placed there, may give him hope for a still higher destiny in the far future." -- Charles Darwin, 1871
Subscribe

  • Apologies

    Well, my attempt at cut-tags failed. And, for whatever reason, LJ won't let me either edit or delete the entries. Sorry!

  • The Personal and the Political: A Dialogue

    Not long ago, on Scalzi’s blog, I made a comment that was sharp, precise, well-worded, inarguable, and wrong. The point I addressed to the…

  • Technical Question: A rare LJ post

    I'm working on a rather longish blog post (dreamcafe.com/words). I'm using WordPress. I'd like to throw in a cut tag for the benefit of those on LJ…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 80 comments

  • Apologies

    Well, my attempt at cut-tags failed. And, for whatever reason, LJ won't let me either edit or delete the entries. Sorry!

  • The Personal and the Political: A Dialogue

    Not long ago, on Scalzi’s blog, I made a comment that was sharp, precise, well-worded, inarguable, and wrong. The point I addressed to the…

  • Technical Question: A rare LJ post

    I'm working on a rather longish blog post (dreamcafe.com/words). I'm using WordPress. I'd like to throw in a cut tag for the benefit of those on LJ…